Skip to Content
Seibert Law Firm Seibert Law Firm
Call Us Today! 843-428-6360
Text Us At 843-594-2101
Schedule Online
Top

What is First Degree Burglary?

|

Under South Carolina law, first-degree burglary is a statutory felony that requires the prosecution to prove specific unlawful entry and intent elements coupled with at least one aggravating circumstance S.C. Code Ann. § 16-11-311, State v. Davis-Kocsis, 436 S.C. 468.

Elements of First-Degree Burglary

To secure a conviction for first-degree burglary, the State must prove the following core elements beyond a reasonable doubt:

  1. Entry of a Dwelling: The defendant must enter a "dwelling" S.C. Code Ann. § 16-11-311, State v. Davis-Kocsis, 436 S.C. 468.
    • Definition of Entry: The State does not have to show that the defendant’s entire body entered the building; the smallest entry of any part of the body (such as a hand or foot) or even an instrument (such as a hook) is sufficient State v. Davis-Kocsis, 436 S.C. 468. Force is not required to gain entry State v. Davis-Kocsis, 436 S.C. 468.
    • Definition of Dwelling: A dwelling includes the living quarters of a building which is used or normally used for sleeping, living, or lodging by a person, or any house, outhouse, apartment, building, shed, or box in which a proprietor, tenant, watchman, clerk, laborer, or lodging person sleeps with a view to protecting property State v. Davis-Kocsis, 436 S.C. 468, S.C. Code Ann. § 16-11-310. Where a building consists of two or more separately occupied or secured units, each unit is deemed a separate building and part of the main building S.C. Code Ann. § 16-11-310.
  2. Without Consent: The entry must be without the consent of the person in lawful possession State v. Davis-Kocsis, 436 S.C. 468, S.C. Code Ann. § 16-11-310. Consent gained through deception, artifice, trick, or misrepresentation constitutes entry without consent State v. Davis-Kocsis, 436 S.C. 468, S.C. Code Ann. § 16-11-310.
  3. Intent to Commit a Crime: The defendant must possess the intent to commit a crime (either a felony or a misdemeanor) inside the dwelling at the time of entry State v. Davis-Kocsis, 436 S.C. 468. If the intent is formed after entry, it is not burglary; however, if the intent existed at the time of entry, the crime is complete even if the intent is subsequently abandoned or the intended crime is not completed State v. Davis-Kocsis, 436 S.C. 468. While intent must exist at entry, a jury may infer this intent from the defendant's subsequent actions and conduct once inside State v. Davis-Kocsis, 436 S.C. 468, State v. Gilliland, 402 S.C. 389.
  4. An Aggravating Circumstance: The State must prove the existence of at least one of the following statutory aggravating circumstances S.C. Code Ann. § 16-11-311, State v. Guthrie, 352 S.C. 103:

Without an aggravating circumstance, the offense constitutes second-degree burglary State v. Guthrie, 352 S.C. 103.

Defenses to First-Degree Burglary

Based on South Carolina statutory and case law, several legal and factual defenses may be raised to challenge the elements of first-degree burglary:

  • Status of the Property (Not a "Dwelling"): A building constructed as a dwelling that has never been occupied, or a vacant apartment that has been abandoned by former tenants and is pending rental, does not legally qualify as a "dwelling" State v. Davis-Kocsis, 436 S.C. 468, State v. Ferebee, 273 S.C. 403. However, a building remains a dwelling if the residents are merely temporarily absent State v. Davis-Kocsis, 436 S.C. 468.
  • Timing of Intent: If the intent to commit a crime inside the structure was formed after the entry occurred, the defendant cannot be convicted of burglary State v. Davis-Kocsis, 436 S.C. 468.
  • Defective Indictment (Jurisdictional Challenge): The specific aggravating circumstance must be alleged in the indictment . Amending an indictment to substitute an entirely different aggravating circumstance (e.g., changing "nighttime entry" to "causing physical injury") is a material change that deprives the court of subject matter jurisdiction over the charge State v. Guthrie, 352 S.C. 103. Any motion to dismiss the indictment for failing to allege the necessary aggravating element must be made before the jury is sworn .

Penalties for First-Degree Burglary

First-degree burglary is a felony carrying severe statutory penalties S.C. Code Ann. § 16-11-311:

  • Imprisonment: The offense is punishable by life imprisonment, which is legally defined as "until death" S.C. Code Ann. § 16-11-311. However, the sentencing court has the discretion to sentence the defendant to a term of imprisonment of not less than fifteen (15) years S.C. Code Ann. § 16-11-311.
  • Ineligibility for Probation or Suspended Sentence: A sentence for first-degree burglary cannot be suspended, and the defendant cannot be placed on probation State v. Jacobs, 393 S.C. 584. Under South Carolina law, a sentencing judge cannot suspend a sentence or grant probation for any offense punishable by death or life imprisonment State v. Jacobs, 393 S.C. 584, S.C. Code Ann. § 24-21-410. Because the maximum potential penalty for first-degree burglary is life imprisonment, it falls strictly within this exception State v. Jacobs, 393 S.C. 584.

Secondary authorities suggest that because the aggravating circumstance is the "essence" of a first-degree charge, the prosecution is required to prove all elements—including prior convictions if used as the aggravating factor—beyond a reasonable doubt to the jury, and a defendant cannot force the prosecution to stipulate to prior convictions to keep them from the jury State v. Guthrie, 352 S.C. 103, State v. Benton, 338 S.C. 151.

First-degree burglary in South Carolina requires proof of non-consensual entry into a dwelling with the contemporaneous intent to commit a crime, along with an aggravating factor such as an armed participant, physical injury, a history of prior burglary convictions, or nighttime entry. Defenses typically focus on challenging the "dwelling" status of the structure, the timing of the criminal intent, or the jurisdictional sufficiency of the indictment. Upon conviction, the defendant faces a mandatory minimum sentence of 15 years up to life imprisonment, with no possibility of a suspended sentence or probation.

Categories: